Showing posts with label analysis. Show all posts
Showing posts with label analysis. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 8, 2008

Idol Thoughts

As we head into Idol Gives Back tonight and look forward to the final few weeks of Idol this season I want to take some time to quickly assess who we have left and how I feel about this season.

First, there is still no clear front runner this season. Also, this is probably the first season where the front runner has changed from week to week. Before the season even started everyone was claiming that Carly was going to be the one to beat. Then in Hollywood Week David A. and Michael had some fantastic clips that were shown on TV and suddenly they became the ones to watch out for. When the Top 24 first sang, Jason Castro came out of nowhere to claim the #2 status and launched himself into front runner status. Then in Top 20 week, David A. sang "Imagine" and claimed the sole spot as the person to beat. In the Top 16 David C. blew everyone away with his rendition of "Hello" and suddenly he became someone to keep an eye on. Jason sang "Hallelujah" and went from dark horse to lead stallion. Meanwhile, David H. was very quickly improving and starting to show that he could make it inot the Top 5. Brooke had two great performances and was suddenly on everyone's radar as a contender as well. Carly was still in the mix but was losing ground and Michael had yet to live up the potential he showed in Hollywood Week.

As we headed into the Top 12 all eyes were on David A., David C., Carly, Jason and Michael. Suddenly David A. faltered by forgetting his lyrics and having a sub-par performance. David C. performed well, as did Carly and Jason. Michael was very quickly losing ground. Out of nowhere, Chikezie had an amazing performance that blew everyone away and suddenly he came became someone to keep an eye on. Inexplicably, we lost David H. that week (who had one of the better voices in the competition) and that just showed how talented this season is.

Top 11 came around and David A. had a better week but it still wasn't living up to the potential he showed during the semi-finals. Everyone was starting to question if he peaked too soon. David C. was quickly forging himself into the new front runner. Jason suddenly stumbled and people finally started realizing that he's very limited as a vocalist. Carly stumbled as well. In fact, just about everyone stumbled this week.

During Top 10 David A. fell even further by picking a song that didn't fit him at all (or did he? The rumor is that his dad picked the song for him). By now everyone is wondering whether David will make it to the end or not. David C. pulled out "Billie Jean" and blew the competition away again. At this point, David C. is the person to beat. Carly came back as well. Michael finally lived up to his hype/potential with his Queen tribute and threw his name into the front-runner hat. Brooke and Jason also had good weeks, keeping them on the list as well.

Top 9 saw the return of David A., whose performance of "Smoky Mountain Memories" quickly launched him back to the front of the pack. David C. had an ok performance but was passed up by Carly and Michael. Brooke and Jason had decent performances.

So there you have it. In my opinion there are 6 people that are jockeying for the #1 position. From week to week the lead changes. All 6 are very talented, but what's great about it is that they're all so different. We have two "Coffeehouse Idols" (Brooke and Jason), two rockers (David C. and Michael) and two straight out singers (David A. and Carly). It's anyone's game right now. Here is the order I think they'll end up in.

David A. - he has such a mature voice for someone his age. He's been performing for so long that he's a pro at it now. However, he's really only shined on ballads. Is he more of a balladeer than a versatile singer? When he's sung faster songs he's shown that he has some breathing issues and can't sustain the notes throughout a phrase. He also has problems hitting some of the lower notes in songs (for examples of both, listing to "Shop Around" from Top 24). He'll need to show that he can tackle a fast song (and sing it well) in order to win.

David C. - he has shown that he's a master at picking the right song for him. He has gotten creative with his choices so it leaves the audience surprised. However, now everyone has caught onto the fact that he looks for obscure covers from alternative bands. If that's the case, are we really going to be blown away each week? That doesn't show as much versatility as we'd like to see. Chris Daughtry played it better by switching up the obscure covers (Ring of Fire) with the straight up renditions (Wonderful World). You have to keep everyone guessing.

Carly - she is a fantastic vocalist; probably the most pure voice in the competition. In order to win, she needs to start looking like she's enjoying what she's doing. Right now, she looks like she is desperate and that's turning people off. She needs to not talk about how much she wants it and just focus on how fun it is to perform and be on stage.

Michael - now that he is starting to live up to his potential he needs to really focus on his song selections because I'm afraid that one wrong move and he'll tumble back down the ladder. It took so long for him to finally have the performance that everyone was waiting for that we're afraid he'll never get back to that status if he falters. David C. seems to have stolen the rocker status away from him so he really needs to stay focused and win it back in order to win it all.

Brooke - is so different because she takes the quiet approach to all of her songs. She likes to strip everything down and really focus on the emotion behind everything. While this is her positive, I also think it's going to be her downfall. Once we get to the top 6 or so, it's going to be the "loud" singers vs. Brooke's sunny side. I don't think she'll win that battle. If she wants to win then she's going to have to step out of her box a little and perform in a way that no one will expect. Unfortunately, I don't think her voice will lend her to that so it's going to be a tough battle for her.

Jason - like Brooke, his take on songs is vastly different from what we're used to from previous males on the show. His laid back vibe (and bright blue eyes) seems to be winning people over. However, unlike just about everyone else on the show, Jason has no experience singing in front of people so this whole thing is just a wild ride for him. He will very quickly be out of his depth with the remaining talent. In order to win he's going to have to pull off some very unique things that no one would expect from him. Also, like Brooke, I don't think he has a strong enough voice to really move outside his coffeehouse vibe. However, if he can keep pulling off songs like "Hallelujah" he may be able to stay around longer than anyone thought.

Syesha - she has a beautiful, clear voice but for some reason no one is getting behind her. I think it's her personal intros before each performance. People are put off by her "look at how great I am attitude" and aren't voting for her. Unless she has the performance of a lifetime week after week I don't see her going too much further in the competition.

Kristy Lee - she actually has a very pretty voice to listen to. She also has a very pretty face to look at. However, she can't seem to have a nice performance to watch. Week after week, she's just bland. However, she's played the game very smartly. By pulling out "God Bless the USA" she knew that middle-America would eat that up and keep her in for country week (knowing that country is her specialty genre and that would keep her in for another week). And now that she's made it to Idol Gives Back it's almost a given that she'll sing "Amazing Grace" (which she has sung several times throughout auditions [and sounds fantastic on]) and middle-America could possibly vote her through again. It's crazy how one song (God Bless the USA) has vaulted her 3 weeks ahead. Unfortunately, I think Kristy Lee has played her trump card and she's got nothing left. I don't think she'll have an "america" song for each of the remaining weeks to keep her in so her days are numbered.

I am looking forward to tonight and very excited to see how the rest of the season plays out. It's going to be really fun watching them claw and sing their way to the #1 spot. All are deserving and I think that the final 2 will be the most talented since Carrie/Bo back in season 4.

Tuesday, March 11, 2008

Top 12, cont.

Jesse gets it right for most of the Top 12, I just have a few additional comments:

Brooke: Don't give her too much clout, just yet. Two weeks of folksy/acoustic performances does not an Idol make. Expect Simon to say in the weeks to follow: "You've been out-sung tonight."
Carly: Don't count her out, just yet. If David A. may have peaked too soon, Carly might be playing this competition just right by saving her best performances for when it counts.
Chickezie: Why so tight-lipped and polite lately? Realize that talking back to the judges didn't quite work as well as you'd like? I agree with Jesse, blandy-McBoring.
Michael: Well, I really just wanted an excuse to think about him again. DREAMY. I'm hoping he is also playing this show strategically (a la Carly) and saving his knockout performances for later.
Ramiele: Something is keeping me from getting behind her completely. She IS better than Jasmine and knowing the Phillopino community they will vote her into at least the Top 6 but her voice just seems forced/affected...
Seyesha: Girl, you're not Whitney Houston (who is slated to release a new album before Christmas 2008!) and you don't have the attitude of some of the other divas of Idol past. She's another one that I think has a false sense of her talent. Good but not great.

Good luck to everyone else. The race officially begins tonight. Tune it to see who is a sprinter and who has been training for the marathon that is AMERICAN IDOL!

Monday, March 10, 2008

Top 12 Preview

So now that we've finally got out Top 12 and the competition gets intense, I think we should take a moment to discuss each individual performer and find out how they're going to do in the competition. Here's my take on this season's Top 12 (in alphabetical order).

Amanda - This year's resident "rocker chick" has had a rough start on Idol already. She's been in the bottom 2 and hasn't had the best critiques from the judges. I feel like she's a one-trick pony and is going to have a really hard time navigating through the various themes each week (can you imagine her singing Gloria Estefan week?) While she brings something very different to the stage I don' t see that carrying her all the way through to the finals. She's already shown that she's pretty vulnerable so I don't see her lasting too much longer. She might do well with Beatles this week but after that it'll be tough.

Brooke - She has actually surprised me. After seeing all the women that made it I thought Brooke was going to get squeezed out because her vocals just aren't as strong as others'. She's got a really nice voice but there isn't a lot of power behind it. She's definitely more of a folky type singer. However, what has really made her stand out (and move towards the front of the pack) is her risks with the songs. The last two weeks she's shown some creativity in arranging songs that would normally not work for her. However, the new arrangements really worked for her and has won over some new fans (myself included). If she can keep bringing the fresh new "coffee-house" vibe to old songs she might go pretty far.

Carly - She is easily the best female vocalist left in terms of power and ease. There is no question that she can sing. However, she has yet to really connect with a song and/or the audience. She just walks up, sings the song, and walks off. If there was no backstory about her previous appearance on Idol or about her record deal we'd know nothing about Carly and would get nothing out of her performances. Also, this blandness isn't just solely on the show. I have her first album and it's pretty easy to see why it didn't sell. The songs are very generic (they don't even have singable hooks) and her voice carries no emotion on them. I think she's going to need to develop some kind of personality when she sings or she's going to go home sooner than anyone thought (could she be our surprise elimination this year?).

Chikezie - I'll be honest, I don't like Chikezie at all. From the first elimination week I thought he was horrible and was surprised he made past that round. His second week wasn't that much better. His third week bored me. I find myself tuning out everytime he's on screen. He has no charisma, his voice sounds exactly like Ruben's (another one who bored me to tears), and he's trying to show some personality by mouthing off to the judges (but always at the wrong time so it looks awkward). After being so close to being eliminated already, I don't see him staying around much longer.

David A. - What is there to say about David that hasn't been said already? This guy is clearly the one to beat. He has a fantastic voice that shows more maturity than most of the contestants left. Plus, he really knows how to get into the emotion of a song and really make you take notice and listen to what he's saying. And then there's his adorable smile and innocent attitude towards everything in the competition. Maybe it's real, maybe it's all an act but right now he's got America in the palm of his hand and we're all just waiting to see what he does each week. The question people are going to have is has he peaked too early with his rendition of "Imagine" or is there more to come? If he doesn't make it into the finals it'll probably be the biggest shock in Idol history.

David C. - Like Brooke, I think David C. has really grown in the last three weeks. When I first saw him I thought he was good but he was definitely a Chris Daughtry wannabe. Each week he got a little bit better until finally last week he blew everyone away with his emo-rock retelling of "Hello". That made stop and take notice about what he was doing to the song and I loved it (as did everyone else). What we need to find out now was if that was just a fluke or a promise of things to come. If it's the latter then we're in for a great ride.

David H. - I'm so happy that David made it into the Top 12 because I honestly didn't think he would. When I saw him in Hollywood Week I fell in love with his vocals. I wasn't disappointed when he started in the Top 24. When he sang the 2nd week I knew that he had finally made it on the radar and would sail through into the Top 12. He has such a strong voice that he can belt out the power ballads but still show off subtle emotion from verse to verse. I think he's hugely talented and should make pretty far down the stretch.

Jason - He is a complete enigma to me. I don't understand while everyone likes him so much. I thought his first performance was ok but it didn't blow me away. Neither did his 2nd. His third was alright but having never heard the song I wasn't sure why everyone liked it so much. Now that I've heard the original version I do have to give him props because that song really came out of nowhere and he nailed it. I do find him interesting though because I keep getting the sense that he just decided to try out on a whim one day and suddenly found himself on the biggest show on the planet. Sometimes he looks like he's just thinking "how the hell did I get here?". I can really see Jason being the quiet guy that no one notices until the dust suddenly settles and he's in the finals. He's going to be one to keep an eye on.

Kristy - The sole survivor of the "4 Bland Blondes". Initially I thought the 4 Bland Blondes were going to make it into the Top 12 but instead it looks like they all split the votes and took each other out. With Kristy left standing she has a lot on her shoulders to make sure the blondes get further along. Her country voice is pleasant to listen to however, Kristy has turned into a blond robot right in front of our eyes. She has no personality(both when she performs and when she's being interviewed). She really needs to step out of her shell when she's performing or she'll go home pretty quickly as well.

Michael - He has become the most frustrating contestant for me this year. When I saw his initial audition I thought he was fantastic and would bring something new and different to the competition. However, since then I have been completely underwhelmed by him. All of his performances have failed to catch my attention or spark any kind of interest. That's what makes it so frustrating, because we've all seen the potential that he has and know that when he finally nails it, it's going to be awesome. However, wanting that and not delivering each week will get tiresome very quickly. He really needs to pull something out of his hat really soon or he's going to be left behind by the Davids.

Ramiele - I so did not want to like Ramiele because I was scared she was going to be another Jasmine (and we've already been through one). However, this little spitfire has (thankfully) proven me wrong. I think she might be female to beat. She has a great personality, she has great stage presence, and she has a powerful voice. As long as she keeps picking good songs that fit her style I think she will do really well in the competition.

Syesha - She is very hit or miss. Syesha has a fantastic voice and reminds me very much of Nadia Turner from Season 4. However, she has a tendency to pick bad (or overdone) songs. She needs to stay away from Whitney or Celine and really try to bring something new to the double because otherwise people are going to get tired of her really quickly.

So those are my thoughts about this Top 12. I do think they're one of the most talented bunch we've had so far. However, based on the last three weeks, I still think that Season 5 was the best Top 12. It'll be very interesting to see what happens tomorrow night now that we can finally compare them against each other. I'm looking forward to it.

If I was to make a prediction right now, here's how it would shake out for me.

12. Chikezie
11. Kristy
10. Amanda
9. Syesha
8. Michael
7. Jason
6. David C.
5. Brooke
4. David H.
3. Carly
2. Ramiele
1. David A.

Tuesday, March 4, 2008

Top 8 Guys

Hey everyone. Sorry I missed last week but I had to work both nights and didn't get a chance to watch the show until really late at night. Tonight I was watching it at a friend's house so I didn't get to blog live but I'm still going to give my thoughts about tonight's performances.

First up is Luke. I thought this was the perfect song choice for him. Yes, it was a little cheesy, but I think that's pretty much what Luke is....cheesy. There is no way he'll win this competition but I thought tonight was his best performance yet. George Michael is the perfect guy to emulate for his voice. I thought the song worked. Luke was having fun on stage and seemed to be really enjoying himself. I liked it. Grade B.

David A.
- It as cool seeing David open up on the piano (just to remind everyone that he's multitalented). I thought the song choice was a little odd for him but it worked. I liked how he changed it up a little bit. In my opinion, this was his weakest performance thus far on the show, but it was still a hell of a lot better than everyone else tonight. It's going to be hard to top last week's performance. I just hope he didn't peak too soon. Grade A-

Danny
- *sigh*. I'm over Danny. I hate mugging of the camera. I hate his diva attitude. I hate his new scarf every week. I thought this performance was a mess. Tainted Love isn't really a singer's song since it's pretty repetative. Danny's voice was all over the place as well (I think it's interesting that his voice doesn't fit what you see on the screen. Closing your eyes, you wouldn't picture Danny to be singing it). I just didn't like anything about this performance. Grade C-

David H.
- I was worried when I noticed that he was singing a Celine Dion song. But David has a really strong voice that was able to channel the song really well. I loved the different emotions he was conveying through the song and changing his voice up to match them. I thought he did a great job and made it into the Top 12. I'm really happy for him! Grade A-

Michael
- this was a perfect song choice for him. He can definitely channel the 80s rock thing. Simple Minds/INXS/early U2 could be good for him to focus on. This was a good performance but once again, I'm not awed by him. I still find him to be pretty blah and I think he's dropped so much ground in the competition (especially after all 3 David's have been performing so well). He needs to really shine on a song or he'll be out around 7th. Grade B

David C.
- when the song first started I thought "Lionel Richie?!" But as the song got going into the chorus I found myself to really LOVE what he had done with the arrangement and changing it into more of a rock-type song. By mid performance he was in total command of it and really created a whole new song with new emotions. It reminded me of an REM type of song. I loved it! Best performance of the night. Grade A+

Jason
- I don't know this song at all so I have no idea if he was good or not. His voice reminds me of Bright Eyes (which isn't a good or bad thing). I still don't understand the appeal of Jason but it was nice to finally see him without the guitar and really singing a song. It was alright for me but I can't say that it really impressed me. I just get the feeling that Jason keeps thinkig "what am I doing on Idol?!". Grade B

Chikezie
- He's singing some Whitney Houston song that I've never heard. His voice was a little pitchy in parts. I'm not a big fan of Chikezie's and he didn't do anything to change my mind tonight. His voice sounds very similar to Ruben and Luther's but for some reason it just bores me (much like Ruben did on season 2). I didn't care for this performance either. Grade C

I feel like tonight is a pretty easy one to predict but watch me get it wrong. The bottom 3 will be Chikezie, Luke and Danny. I think the two going home will be Chikezie and Danny.

So my picks for the Top 6 guys are: David A, David C, David H, Jason, Michael and Luke. I was two off from my initial predictions. I can't wait to see if I get those right.

Wednesday, February 27, 2008

Top 10 Men

I was working all day doing interviews for my staff. Then I get off of work and go straight to Barnes to work there as well. Then I get home at midnite, sit down in front of my TV and find out that TiVo screwed up and didn't tape Idol today. BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! Luckily, Rickey is on top of his game and had all the performances on his blog already so I was able to watch them there.

First and foremost, I fully support David Archuleta. That kid is DA BOMB! That was possibly the best performance I have ever heard of that song. The emotion and the vocals were AMAZING. I agree that it was one of the best performances on Idol EVER (take that Jordin Sparks!) This kid is flying right to the finale. It's so hard to see him losing now.

Which brings me to my second thought of the night. Go David Hernandez! I love this guy. I loved him during Hollywood week and was secretly hoping he'd do well, but I didnt want to admit that I liked him because I thought he'd go out in the first week like Rudy Cardenas did last season. But I think I can finally come out and say that I'm a David H. fan. I would love to see him continue to grow (much like Elliott Yamin did) and make it to Top 3 but I don't think that will happen.

As for the rest, YAWN! I thought the rest of the show was pretty boring. Michael Johns was horrible tonight. Such a bad song choice and he was flat the whole song. I thought it was awful. He just lost a lot of steam.

Jason Yeager
just sounds like a Vegas lounge singer. He needs to go. Luke was alright but I don't think he'll make it much further.

Robbie Carrico
wasn't rock at all and he needs to stop playing up the rocker thing.

Jacuzzi (Chikezie) was boring again. I'm over him.

I don't get the appeal of Jason Castro. I thought he was average last week and not better this week. I just don't get it.

David Cook was actually pretty good. He finally did look like the rocker star that he claims he is. At least it looked like a real concert.

Lastly, there was Danny Noriega. I hate, hate HATE the song that he sang. Ruben Studdard sang it in Season 2 and bored me with it then. I have yet to hear a version of it that is good. This was no better. In fact, Ruben's boring interpretation of the song sang circles around Danny. I think Danny might have a big scare tonight. We'll see what happens, but either way his stock dropped like a brick after the show was over. We'll see how the women do.

Tuesday, February 26, 2008

Top 10 Men - The Davids & The Rest


For me, tonight was all about the Davids. David Hernandez and David Archuleta were definitely the top 2 with David Cook still leaving enough room for improvement in the future. I've read that David H. is gay which makes me want to support him even more while David A. still impresses but I'm ready for the "aww shucks" routine needs to end (anyone remember Melinda Doolittle doing the same thing last year?).
I realized tonight that this is going to be an interesting season for me because I always comment each year that I want to watch a less experienced singer develop and there aren't too many of those contestants this year...


On the other side of the spectrum I put Jason Yeager and Robbie Carrico. Jason is out of his league (and not very good at dressing himself) and Robbie is getting "out rocked" by Michael Johns and David Cook. Votefortheworst.com is still backing Danny Noriega and he had enough improvement, I believe, to keep him in another week.

Wednesday, February 20, 2008

Top 12 Women

Let's get it started!

First up is Kristy Lee Cook - "Rescue Me" - she's more of a country singer so I'm curious to see if she'll be able to pull off the Carrie Underwood thing and navigate through the themes effectively. The song choice is good but her voice seems a little thin for the song. It's nice, but seems to lack some power that would really make the song soar. Like this it's just a good version of the song, but kinda boring. She's way hot though. Grade B

Joanne Borgella - wow, her voice doesn't sound that good tonight. I have to agree that i thought she'd have a more soulful voice. that could end up hurting her in the end as that what people are expecting to hear from her. She's missing a lot of the higher notes which could be from the flu that the girls are dealing with plus she's looking really nervous. I didn't get the ending to the song. She should have stopped after the chorus. Grade C+

Alaina Whitacker - Carrie's twin needs to give a good performance because she's got a lot of talented singers to compete against and she hasn't had a lot of air time. Hmm, good start. The lower notes were a little problem but by the time she kicked into the chorus she found her zone. I think she's going to be compared to Carrie a lot because she seems to have the same type of voice and seems to perform very similar to her. Good job though. Best of the first three we've seen. Grade B+

Amanda Overmeyer - Whoa! I don't get this at all. You can't understand a thing that she's saying and can hardly hear her over the guitar. I don't get her Elvira hairdo. This whole thing is a hot mess! I had higher hopes for her. Grade D

Amy Davis - Here's another one that we didn't get a lot of airtime on before. It'll be interesting to see what she does. Her pictures floating around the internet are HOT though. She should definitely try to get into modeling if she hasn't already. She sounded good in Hollywood week but then is all over the place tonight. The song is boring and her voice is grating. This is not good at all. Grade D+

Brooke White - she has a really nice, pure voice but I think her voice might be a little on the weaker side compared to the rest. It'd be interesting to see how she does. Again, she's got a nice voice but it's not strong enough for this song. To borrow from Simon, it sounds like good karaoke. It's a nice rendition but not awesome. She needs to work on her showmanship as well. Grade B

Alexandrea Lushington - "Spinning Wheel". Ugh, what's up with everyone tonight. These are all such bland performances. finally, near the middle she picks it up and gives the song some life. However, she keeps missing some of the higher notes. also, after having Bo knock it out of the park during his season this is a bit of a let down. Grade B-

Kady Malloy - Does "Britney Spears" have a real voice? Let's find out. Whoa! She sounds great! Totally different from Britney. A little deeper than I was expecting. It was a quiet, sincere performance. It was really good. My favorite of the night so far. Grade A-

Asia'H Epperson - "Piece of My Heart" - FINALLY! Someone is singing well, having fun and picked a good song for their voice. Best one of the night by far. She was having fun and enjoying the moment. Grade A

Romiele Malubay - "You don't Have You Love" - i love this song! She's really holding back on her voice to make it more seductive. I like it though. Just waiting for her to belt out. She sounds great on this song and is emoting it very well. I really like it. Just became my favorite of the night. Grade A

Syesha Mercado - "Tobacco Road" - Syesha has a great voice, which she showed off at Hollywood Week. She continues to show it off this week. Great showmanship and has a powerful voice. Great ending. Grade B+

Carly Smithson - Here she comes, "the chosen one". First week and she already has the pimp spot. They're doing everything they can to make sure this girl wins. Let's see what she comes up with. OMG, this is such a boring song. But she sounds great and effortless. The judges are going to love it just to pimp her even more. I really thought she would have chosen something that would have showed off her voice a lot more. This really didn't do anything for her. Big disappointment. Grade B i actually completely agree with everything Simon is saying on this.

So there you have it. Overall, I think this show was a big disappointment. I guess the guys are better as a whole this season. My bottom 3 would be Amanda, Amy, and Joanne. However I don't think that Amanda will actually make it to the bottom so I would probably put in Alexandrea Lushington. Going home tomorrow will be Amanda and Joanne. I can't wait to see what happens.


Tuesday, February 19, 2008

Top 12 Men!

Here we are! Finally it all begins tonight. As I did last year, I will be blogging these as they are happening so you can get my initial reactions before the judges make their comments. We'll see if I am anywhere near them. Let's the games begin!
[ ryan ]: Jesse and I generally agree on our recaps (plus he usually gets his post up first) so I am only going to add a few comments here and there...

David Hernandez - I don't have David in my top 6 (he's actually #7 for me) so I'm kinda pulling for him to make it through. In Hollywood Week he showed off an awesome voice that blew me away. I'm hoping he does the same thing again tonight. He has a great voice tonight, once again very strong. I love the gospelly opener. However, he's so nervous that he's not letting himself get into the performance and it's coming across as very stiff. If he just relaxes a bit he'll be a lot better. Missed the last run but overall I really liked it. Grade B+
David surprised me and made my Top 6 tonight. Loved the opening acapella.

Chikezie - What's up with the 70s tux he's wearing? He looks like Dumb & Dumber. He has a nice voice but I think the song is going to be too boring. He doesn't really do anything unique with it. It's very "loungy". Yeah, i'm definitely bored with this whole thing. Wow, he's talking back for no real reason. Simon is right about his suit. It looks like Chikezie could be one of the first to go. Grade C
I'm with Jesse on this one; it's WAY to early to argue with Simon... especially when you're wrong and dressed in that awful suit.

David Cook - "Happy Together" - I'm excited to see him because I think he has a good rocker voice. But I also think he's also trying too hard to be a rocker so it'll be interesting to see what he does. Oooh, I like the originality behind the song. I'm digging his voice but he's missing a lot of notes here and there. I'm not really buying that he's a rocker. He's more of a faux-rocker. Good performance though. Grade B-
Gave a little vibe of Constantine Maroulis (Season 4) with the close-to-the-mouth mic and sideways glances. But I think there is tremendous potential in him.

Jason Yeager - "Moon River" - Finally, we get to see this random person that has had no exposure but made it to the Top 24. I'm very curious to hear what he sounds like. Well, he has a nice voice but there's really nothing special behind it. The song isn't really doing anything to showcase his voice in any way. He seems to be singing it as if it's his last time on stage and wants to savior every second of it. That's good to see but didn't really make for a great performance. Overall it was just ok. Grade C+
Why does his son have a girl's haircut from the 60's?

Robbie Carrico - I really like this guy's voice. He's a lot more rocker than David Cook is, yet still has a pop quality to his voice. It'll be exciting to watch him navigate the theme weeks. Oooh, i'm loving this so far. This is a great song for his voice. I do think he needs a little more work on his stage presence but he sounds great all throughout the song. Best performance of the night so far. Grade B+
I was bored.

David Archuleta
- "Better Shop Around" - ok, here we go. It's the first "chosen one" for this season. Let's see if he can handle the pressure. I'm not a big fan of the song choice for him but his voice sounds really strong. Plus, he's such a cute kid with a wide-eyed smile that it's really easy to get pulled into his performance. His run at the end was awesome! This kid is gonna light up the stage. Grade A
HAHA, his interaction with Ryan is priceless. He's such a shy, awkward kid that has a personality that's going to win everyone over.
Girls are going to go crazy for him. Sanjaya crazy. But this time it is deserved.

Danny Noriega
- "Jailhouse Rock" - wow, his voice wasnt' what I was expecting it to sound like. It's actually for this song. He's getting a little off beat but holding it together nicely. I didn't care for his dancing or his ending to the song though. Not really what I expected from him. Grade B-
I didn't like Danny until tonight. The song seemed to get out of control with the tempo but I felt like Jesse that his voice sounded more pleasant and recordable tonight than in previous auditions. Is Danny American Idol's version of Christian from Project Runway ("hot" = "fierce")? Also, the EXTENDED arguing amongst the judges over Danny was very reminiscent of RJ Helton's experience in Season 1. When Paula kept talking about colors was that hinting at a rainbow? Then Ryan warned Danny that Simon might "double snap" back at him. C'mon guys, let's get above the stereotypes.

Luke Menard - wow, watching his audition I'm actually surprised he made it through. It didn't sound good at all. Now I'm even more curious to hear what he sounds like. Well he has a "higher" type voice which is cool but he's missing notes left and right. He sorta pulls it together on the chorus. It's a boring performance though. I don't think this is good at all. Nice falsetto at the end. We'll see if his looks save him tonight. Grade C-
Vanilla, sincere with hints of a good falsetto.

Colton Berry
- "Suspicious Minds" - It'll be interesting to compare him to Daughtry who sang this in Season 5. I'm actually surprised. I really like this song on him. He has a tinge of the grunge in his voice to make him interesting. He looks very comfortable on the stage and seems to be having a lot of fun. Grade B
Sometimes it's a good thing to say you've watched American Idol from Season 1 (like Jesse and I) but for Colton I think it means that he tried to STUDY American Idol. He was mugging/posing for the camera way too much for me. This was Danny's Elvis minus the attitude.

Garrett Haley - "Breaking Up Is Hard to Do" - Finally, we get to see the guy that has a total of 20secs on Idol so far this season. He's the biggest mystery of all this year. Let's see what he can do and why he was chosen. Wow, he has a high nasally voice. Not what I was expecting at all. It sounds very similar to EJ Day from Season 1. This is a boring performance. He's not doing anything at all. His voice goes pretty nasal at times and not really pleasant to listen to. I think the crowd reaction says it all, they're not responding to anything he's doing. Grade D
I don't see the comparisons that were made about Garrett, instead I see a hobbit who sings like a chipmunk. He is awkwardly positive but just very strange. Also, he said "I want to show myself to the world"... contestants have used that line before but it totally creeped me out when he said it
.


Jason Castro - Here's another one that we have no idea what he sounds like. I can't wait to hear him. Hm, I like the vibe of the song that he's giving off. It's cool to see him perform with his guitar but I hope it doesn't become a crutch for him. He has an interesting voice; there's a little grit, a little pop. It's all kinda like Jack Johnson/Ryan Cabrera. Overall it's ok. It'll be interesting to see what he does next week. Grade B-
Jason Mraz-ish and I LOVED IT. So likable and beautiful eyes. I hope he gains some confidence so he will stay for a long time.

Michael Johns - "Light My Fire" - Michael is my 2nd favorite of the guys (after David A) so I am really excited to see what he can do. Well it's a good song choice for him. He definitely has the rocker thing down and he looks comfortable on the stage. However I didn't care for some of the vocals. Not sure what it is but it didn't really click all the way for me. But he was one of the better performances of the night. He's another one that I am curious to see how he changes it up throughout the themes. Grade A-
First I need to stop drooling because damn he is sexy to me! But I was proud that I was able to listen with an unbiased ear. I wasn't crazy about the vocal but his stage presence is undeniable and I hope he doesn't do as much of the rocker stuff and instead lets us hear some more singing. Or maybe I just want him to sing me a love song.

So that does it for the first night of the season. As promised, a very strong group this year. It's definitely going to be really tough. Some guys sailed through to next week (David A. and Michael) and some are going to have a really tough time.

I think the bottom 3 for tomorrow are: Garrett, Luke and Jason Yeager. I was going to put Chikezie in there but I think he'll squeak by. Then again, Luke's look might pull him up high enough that he'll move out and bump Chikezie down. In any event, I think the two going home are Garrett and Jason Yeager. Both suffered from no show time during the auditions to having subpar performances tonight. They really needed to have an amazing performance tonight to win some votes but it didn't work out for either of them.
I'd like to see Chikezie go for his attitude but at least that made him stick out. So I agree that Garrett and Luke are the first to go home.

Now on to the women! Bring it on.

Thursday, May 17, 2007

Shocked and Stunned

Well, the shocker elimination of the season finally happened last night and Melinda was eliminated from the show. To say I was shocked is an understatement. I sat there staring at the TV with my jaw on the floor throughout all of Melinda's montage footage. I could not believe that the producers actually let her go. I think that she's just too "mature" for Idol. She is already a first-class performer and singer and it seems like there is no more growth for her. She's going to have a great career so she shouldn't have to worry about that. I just think that American tends to like people that actually grow while on the show so we can see their confidence boost every week and watch their performances get better and better. We didn't get that with Melinda but we did with Blake and especially with Jordin. As stunned as I am that Melinda is gone, I am actually pretty excited with the Blake/Jordin finale. It was what I was hoping for as we started coming down the home stretch. I really think that it's an even playing field right now and both have a good chance of winning. As for me, I'm voting for Blake.

Friday, May 11, 2007

Simon's Choice

Apparently I DO think too deeply about American Idol because today I started thinking about Tuesday's Top 3 showdown. More specifically, each contestant will be singing three songs: one they choose for themselves, one chosen by a judge (Randy, Paula or Simon) and one chosen by Clive Davis. Historically speaking, Simon pairs up with the contestant most likely to win (or at least gives them the song with the most potential to help them win).

So Idol fans, who will gain the power behind SIMON'S CHOICE?

Wednesday, May 9, 2007

Strategy?

Maybe I over-analyze these things, but how much do you think the contestants (especially now six seasons into this show/contest) strategize throughout the competition?

Comments have been made about certain contestants peaking too soon or conversely really turning the heat up at different points in the competition. I guess I wonder if these "kids" are really more savvy then we might think.

Consider these two ideas then discuss on the message boards...

What if Melinda has been waiting to unleash some more "WOW" performances until she is sure to be in the final? Consistent, good performances have gotten her this far and maybe she wants to blow everyone else away in the end? It seems to me that this would be right time to have an "off" night, gain some sympathy votes, slide into the Top 3 and then snap back to her semi-final quality performances.

Why has Blake started beat-boxing again? Does he realize that he needs that differentiation amongst the finalists now, more than before? Will he stop again if he makes the Top 3?

Tuesday, April 10, 2007

Is Idol About the Music or Just Good TV?

LA Times ran an article yesterday about American Idol and what it does for pop music. Is it actually a singing competition that showcases amazing vocals and re-introduces classic songs to a younger generation? Or is it simply a smart TV show that focuses more on the antics and the people to make it entertaining?

"If "American Idol" were really first and foremost a singing competition, as Simon Cowell keeps grousing it is, we'd all be talking about Melinda Doolittle's near-flawless, jazz-inflected performances, for music lovers the true highlight of the No. 1-rated show's sixth season.

Instead, America is engaged in a national debate about Sanjaya Malakar's hair."

To continue reading the article click here.

So which is it, a show that gets America talking about people or a show that really is about the music business? Personally, I think it's both. For me, the show has opened me up to a lot of older, classic songs that I hadn't heard before (and yes, that does say a lot about my exposure to older music.) And you can't deny what the show has done for some of it's breakout stars (i.e. Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood). Idol has definitely made an impact on the current music scene and I am sure it will continue to do so in the future. But the show is also (and sometimes even more) entertaining when discussing each of the contestants. We all have our favorites that we follow and hope will go far. And because of those favorites, we can't believe that other people follow different contestants. Discussing the pros and cons of each of the singers and arguing about who is better is what makes the show fun and interesting. Why do people like Sanjaya so much when clearly Melinda is the best singer of the competition? How can personality win over talent? For these reasons, it'll be very interesting to see how Super Male Voice (Chinese Idol) will do since they're taking all of the extra stuff away and just making the competition about the songs and the voice. It may truly end up being a singing competition, but it might not be very interesting to watch. If American Idol is really just a singing competition then we could have crowned Melinda the winner at her audition. But since there's so much more to the show everyone is on edge trying to figure out what will happen next. That's what makes the show fun. That's what keeps people tuned in. So for me, Idol is a mix of both talent and good tv.

Are 'American Idol' Singers Too Similar?

One of the more honest and insightful articles about this season of American Idol [via MSNBC Interactive]
...In the end, it isn’t that this season’s top ten are bad, as it seemed like it might be early on, and it isn’t that they’re too good, exactly. It’s that it doesn’t feel like every contestant does the same death-defying stunt of risking elimination every week. If the six apparently doomed performers meet their appropriate fate, there’s no suspense, and if they don’t, there’s no justice. Who knew this show relied on either?
Click here to read the rest of the article.